The fresh new genealogists all of the contemplate it extreme you to definitely Nicholas’ partner Clementia try integrated right here due to the fact, around normal issues, she would never be stated. When Susanna from the particular after time received out to a special guardian, brand new wife of this protector was not mentioned.
This will mean that Queen John invested a while truth be told there and the possibility of an amorous liaison having Clementia can be obtained
What follows here’s a theory advanced by certain eminent genealogists, but it’s fair to state that the brand new findings was hotly contested!
It theory contributes to a great and you will curious ‘twist’ on the story out of Joanna, which may focus admirers out of HBD!
On the surface, there is absolutely nothing to recommend one union within hostage, Susanna of Wales and Clementia, wife off Nicholas de- Verdun. Although not, sensation of certain genealogists which have overseas hostages, such as for example youths, could have been that they was basically tend to place which have family unit members, if any was indeed available.
Bouncing toward 1236, discover an admission regarding Tewkesbury annals and that pertains to Joanna’s mommy since the “King Clemencie!” They reads to some extent:
Now, it is known the mom from Joanna was named Clementia (Clemence?
In such a case the brand new monk are obviously indulging from inside the gothic legalism. Just before her passing, Joanna is legitimised from the ser Skotsk kvinner Pope. Based on that legitimisation, the newest Tewksbury monk plainly took it abreast of themselves to raise Joanna’s mother into reputation out-of King, because if their unique mom was actually Queen John’s spouse! It is true but not, that Queen John and you can Clementia was indeed never married. By the writing about Joanna’s mommy as “Queen” Clementia, the fresh new monk whom filed Joanna’s death try indicating his significant admiration to own Joanna, although not attempting to change the genuine circumstances.
Are you aware that identity of Clementia de- Verdun, Paget implies that she are new daughter away from Roger de Dauntsey, out-of Wiltshire. One genealogist takes into account they high one to Clementia regarded off Wiltshire once the he has realized that King John had a strong connection to help you that condition, they being the home from his safest partners, the fresh Longespee, ilies and you may Geoffrey Fitz Peter.
Genealogists are finding that name ‘Clementia’ are very uncommon one of English noblewomen from the period. In one single desk off women’s brands which had been accumulated, there have been just two situations of one’s identity “Clementia” off a maximum of 1407 ladies in the newest shot! The fact anybody titled Clementia will be of this Susanna is extreme.
Therefore! The data was suggestive, yet not conclusive, that for the 1228, Susanna, due to the fact a hostage, gotten out over the care of her maternal grandma, today wife away from Nicholas de Verdun!!
The newest Scottish genealogists of MacDuffs’ keep one to Susanna ferch Llywelyn was created 1214 from inside the Gwynnedd, Wales and passed away c. 1259 within the Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland. She partnered Malcolm MacDuff, Earl regarding Fife inside 1230 along with a couple students: Sir Colbran MacDuff, Earl out-of Fife, born 1245, died 1270 and you may MacDuff MacDuff born 1247.
Without a doubt, you’ll find prevent objections to any or all which conjecture! Queen John got of several mistresses and maybe as much as eight illegitimate college students. The caretaker off Joanna would-have-been created circa 1172 and you can marriageable circa 1184. Joanna by herself came into this world circa 1191 (14 years of age in the course of her marriage so you’re able to Llywelyn). Rohese, the known genuine child out-of Nicholas de- Verdun and his wife Clementia came to be circa 1210-1213. If Clementia was the mother off Joanna, she would can be found in their unique later 30’s, very early 40’s whenever having a baby to help you Rohese! Not hopeless, some state, but not likely.